05/18/2024

Some Crim

Track the Untold Stories

Sophie Hartman

‘The spirit of subversion and hubris’: Mom falsely accused of medical child abuse files multimillion-dollar lawsuit against hospital, police, and child welfare authorities

Sophie Hartman speaks about her daughter&#8217s condition in a 2019 Tv set job interview (Screengrab by using KING-Television set)

A Seattle-location mom formerly accused of health care youngster abuse and subsequently cleared of any and all wrongdoing is now using the battle to her previous accusers in a multimillion-greenback lawsuit.

Sophie Hartman, on behalf of herself and her two small small children, accuses the Washington Department of Children, Youth and People (DCYF) and many other named defendants of battery, wrong imprisonment, fabrication of evidence, and other constitutional violations, in accordance to the 71-website page lawsuit received by Regulation&Criminal offense.

&#8220To defend against fake medical accusations and a myriad of violations of specialist criteria, the Hartman family has invested thousands and thousands of bucks on lawyers just to keep the spouse and children alongside one another and Sophie out of jail,&#8221 the complaint reads. &#8220The genuine harm to the family members is wide and the spirit of subversion and hubris with which a variety of defendants betrayed the Hartman relatives is shocking.&#8221

Relevant Protection:

    In May well 2021, Hartman was billed with one particular count of assault of a kid in the next diploma and one particular domestic violence rely of tried assault of a boy or girl in the second degree for taking her then-6-calendar year-aged daughter to upwards of 474 health care appointments given that 2016.

    Hartman pointed out that her daughter experienced been identified with the uncommon neurological problem recognized as Alternating Hemiplegia of Childhood (AHC) by doctors at Duke University Clinical Centre. In North Carolina, she had been dealt with by those people medical doctors for some three a long time. The diagnosis only became a difficulty in Washington State.

    &#8220Contrary to the allegations of the King County Prosecuting Legal professional, the child&#8217s diagnosis was designed by far more than a single doctor, is reputable, and is dependent on a significant history beyond the reviews and details provided by Ms. Hartman,&#8221 protection lawyers Adam Shapiro and Jessica Goldman reported in a assertion just after the arrest.

    Even just before that, however, at the insistence of health professionals and nurses at Seattle Little ones&#8217s Healthcare facility, the DCYF opened a dependency circumstance versus Hartman in an exertion to take away her little ones from her custody.

    &#8220It failed,&#8221 the lawsuit notes — with a courtroom identifying, right after a 49-day trial, that the healthcare facility had been involved in kid abuse-targeted surveillance endeavours of the Hartman family that had been &#8220deeply flawed.&#8221

    &#8220The wrong abuse was painstakingly debunked by a trial,&#8221 the criticism notes. &#8220The loved ones introduced in court the comprehensively-documented professional medical proof including from environment-primary physicians in the field of AHC. It was founded that there experienced been no basis for the removal of C.H. or M.H. in the first position.&#8221

    Immediately after the study course of an exhaustive and exhausting legal protection on two fronts, the Hartman household was basically broke, the lawsuit suggests.

    &#8220In overall, the Hartman family members has used above $2,850,000 preventing the baseless allegations from them and unwell-established prison charges brought at the urging of [Seattle Children’s Hospital] and DCYF,&#8221 the complaint reads. &#8220The Hartmans&#8217 money decline in the course of this process involved publishing a bond of $100,000 to hold Sophie from owning to invest intensive time in jail right after her arrest for prices of assault. The posting of the bond resulted in the placement of a lien on Sophie&#8217s household&#8217s household and a payment of significant money to attain the bond. To increase cash, the family members incurred important additional charges, together with liquidation of retirement assets.&#8221

    At the identical time, Sophie Hartman experienced been comprehensively maligned in the push and the resulting well-liked creativeness, the lawsuit states.

    From the submitting, at duration:

    This led to the using of the little ones in a law enforcement raid, the charging of Sophie criminally in a maximally humiliating way, a variety of strangers rifling by means of Sophie&#8217s non-public prayer journals and each individual private self-assurance to sift devious motives from a loving mom&#8217s agony at making an attempt to support her struggling boy or girl, and intensive other Orwellian intrusions. Cherrypicked pages from people prayer journals ended up then used openly in courtroom to endeavor to paint a photo that she was an abusive mom. This led to a media frenzy that painted Sophie as an abusive mom who built up that her baby was sick for interest. The media described, for instance, that Sophie &#8220went on a PR tour for her unwell, adopted African little one&#8221 and that she, was a &#8220white, Jesus-loving previous missionary&#8221 who strapped her &#8220little Black woman born in Zambia&#8221 into a wheelchair, amid other outrageous and enormously humiliating statements about Sophie which were fully phony. This also led to death threats in opposition to Sophie, forcing her to flee from her property and cover in a hotel for security.

    &#8220Quite a few defendants contorted information, manipulated and hid evidence, and outright lied, using comprehensive cash equipped by the Point out, the spouse and children&#8217s very possess healthcare insurance plan, and federal authorities funds to try to destroy the Hartman loved ones,&#8221 the lawsuit goes on to allege — connecting some of the defendants to the &#8220humiliating&#8221 media strategies against the family.

    Unable to continue having to pay attorneys and problems performed in quite a few techniques, the condition and the loved ones agreed the felony expenses in opposition to Sophie Hartman would be dismissed with prejudice and replaced with a lone misdemeanor demand — in exchange for a regime whereby other people were being authorized to control her daughter&#8217s overall health for awhile.

    The misdemeanor charge was subsequently dropped as nicely.

    The mom attained healthcare final decision-building control about her daughter in November 2023, the lawsuit notes. Right before that, nonetheless, and as a final result of the compelled treatment routine where by health professionals &#8220disregarded&#8221 insight into ACH, Hartman&#8217s daughter has experienced lasting harm.

    &#8220The Hartmans have been the victims of a procedure of secrecy and unchecked authority without having accountability, which led to the separation of the Hartman family based on phony and outrageous statements of little one abuse or neglect of C.H.,&#8221 the lawsuit reads. &#8220For two a long time, quite a few Defendants secretly established the family up primarily based on wild and proof-free of charge allegations of abuse or neglect, and misused the relatives&#8217s trust in health-related specialists to forcibly take out the little ones from their mom Sophie&#8217s care.&#8221

    Hartman is represented in her civil scenario by Seattle-dependent lawyer Eliot M. Harris. The 5-count lawsuit filed in King County Remarkable Court docket seeks extra than $2.85 million in compensation, prejudgment curiosity, legal professional&#8217s costs, and compensatory, consequential, exemplary, reduction of consortium, and punitive damages.

    &#8220Seattle Children&#8217s normally takes our duty to defend the overall health and safety of our sufferers critically, but we are not able to remark on this distinct circumstance thanks to pending litigation,&#8221 the healthcare facility at the centre of the controversy and litigation advised Tacoma-dependent Fox affiliate KCPQ.

    The lawsuit is adamant about the &#8220very actual&#8221 analysis that was, &#8220for motives that elude any logic,&#8221 spun by a handful of doctors, nurses, and law enforcement into the notion that Hartman had conjured up her daughter&#8217s &#8220indicators for uses of publicity and to provide guides.&#8221

    &#8220The Hartman household gained,&#8221 the lawsuit reads. &#8220The relatives was divided for 492 times, each member experienced terrific harm, and it price tens of millions of bucks in attorneys&#8217 expenses, expenses, and detrimental tax outcomes from premature asset liquidation to stave off the assault. Soon after those people 492 times, the relatives proved what experienced been very clear to authentic professionals and common perception all along — that there was no abuse and Sophie experienced supplied her all to protect her kids.&#8221

    Be part of the discussion 

    The write-up ‘The spirit of subversion and hubris’: Mother falsely accused of clinical youngster abuse documents multimillion-dollar lawsuit in opposition to clinic, law enforcement, and youngster welfare authorities initial appeared on Legislation & Crime.